7500 Dixie Hwy, Suite BFairfield, OH 45014

Insurance professionals that have your back – Family Owned Business

Call Us 513-860-0666

Call Us Today!



We are happy to assist you in selecting the best coverage.

Get a Quote


We get you the right coverage for the right price.

Get a Quote


We offer free quotes and dedicated personal service.

Get a Quote

Our primary focus is auto insurance especially when it comes to writing SR-22 bonds.

1st Choice Insurance is a leading insurance agency located in Fairfield, OH serving Hamilton, Butler, Warren, and surrounding counties.  Family-owned and dedicated to the community, 1st Choice Insurance has offered its friendly and personalized service in the greater Cincinnati area for over 30 years.

Our insurance service covers you in all aspects of your life but we specialize in auto insurance and SR22 coverage. We have a wide array of insurance policies that includes auto, motorcycle insurance and recreational vehicles

Click Here to Check Your BMV Driving Record!

What Our Clients Say Testimonial Review Stars

Great place friendly staff I recommend them to everyone

-Cboo Ballin

The staff here is excellent and is always polite and understanding never rude

-Jamie Hamilton

Great place with comparable rates! Friendly and helpful service!

-Deloris Eversole

When every "big name" auto insurance company wanted to charge me anywhere from $400-$900 for coverage and SR22 coverage, Yes I said $900, 1st Choice Insurance quoted me a simple $150 deposit and $87 a month ongoing. They were fast, simple, friendly and an overall piece of mind. I am...

-Ashley Wormley

Staff was friendly very helpful!!

-Jeremy Williams

This is a great place to get your insurance. The people there are wonderful,very good people very good personality.

-Lafayette Lewis

I'm a first time customer and I'll tell you the whole experience was awesome. The are knowledgeable and understanding of what you are looking for or need. I would recommend this place to others in search of good quality service and insurance for your vehicle. 👍👍👍🙂

-Kyle Young

Leave Us a Review

The greatest testament that our customers can provide is by sharing their experience.

View More
Acceptance Insurance Logo
Commonwealth Logo
Dairyland Logo
Founders Logo
Progressive Logo
Trexis Logo